Green Diesel – New Rules in Finance Act

Home/IWAI Waterways Discussion Forum/Green Diesel – New Rules in Finance Act
Green Diesel – New Rules in Finance Act2008-01-31T21:29:12+00:00

IWAI Forums IWAI Forums IWAI Waterways Discussion Forum Green Diesel – New Rules in Finance Act

Viewing 24 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • Colin Becker
      Moderator
        Post count: 5097

        Greetings,

        In the Finance Bill 2008 published today the Minister has unveiled the new
        rules that will apply to the use of “Green” diesel for private pleasure
        navigation in RoI.

        The Press release is at http://www.finance.gov.ie/viewdoc.asp?DocID=5162 and
        there are links to the bill and the explanatory memorandum at the bottom of
        the page.

        >From 1 Novemeber the rate of duty will be 368.05 Euro per 1000 litres – the
        same as road diesel. Thats in Section 65 on page 91.

        Section 66 on then goes on to explain how the tax-man will collect the extra
        revenue:
        ===================begins==============
        Subsection (a) iii defines “private pleasure craft” as follows:
        ”’private pleasure navigation’ means navigation in any craft, by its owner
        or the natural or legal person who enjoys its use either through hire or
        through any other means, for other than commercial purposes, and in
        particular other than for the carriage of passengers or goods, the supply of
        services for consideration or for the purposes of public authorities;”,

        Subsection (c) then says:

        (c) by inserting the following after section 97-

        97A.-(1) Subject to subsections (2) and (3), heavy oil which has been taxed
        at the rate specified in Schedule 30 2 for other heavy oil (referred to in
        this section as ”marked gas oil”) may be used for private pleasure
        navigation.

        (2) Where subsection (1) applies, the owner of the craft used for private
        pleasure navigation shall, not later than the first day of March following
        the calendar year in which the marked gas oil was purchased for such use,
        deliver to an officer-

        (a) a return, in such form as the Commissioners may require, of the quantity
        in litres of marked gas oil purchased in that calendar year, and

        (b) payment of an amount of mineral oil tax calculated at the rate of 32.069
        cent per litre (which is the difference between the mineral oil tax rate for
        marked gas oil
        and the rate for heavy oil used for private pleasure navigation) on such
        quantity

        (3) The owner referred to in subsection (2) shall, together with vouched
        receipts for all purchases of the marked gas oil concerned, maintain a
        record of such purchases, in such form as the Commissioners may require.
        ==========ends================
        The somewhat confusing wording arises because what the 2008 Bill does is
        amend an earlier Act.

        My reading (and I’m only a simple engineer, not a parliamentary draughtsman
        or a lawyer) is that from 1 November of this year we will be required to
        keep a record of any “Green” diesel we buy for our boats along with the
        receipts and then between 1-January and 31-March each year make a return to
        the revenue saying how much we bought and enclosing a cheque for the extra
        duty payable.

        Two things aren’t clear to me:

        1) What happens if I buy “Red” diesel in Northern Ireland

        and

        2) How hirers of hire-boats will cope (because my reading is that the hirers
        will be liable for the extra duty.)

        These are questions that we will pose to the Powers That Be in the Dept. of
        Finance.

        Colin Becker
        Project/Development Officer, IWAI
        “IWAI – The Voice of the Waterways”

      • Ewan Duffy
        Spectator
          Post count: 81

          The word “unconstitutional” applies to the exclusion of full duty for green
          diesel used for the purposes of public authorities, on the basis that the
          State cannot favour itself. The fact that the State would be paying itself
          is irrelevant.

          On Jan 31, 2008 9:29 PM, Colin Becker (Project Officer, IWAI) <
          colin_becker[AG]iwai.ie> wrote:

          > Greetings,
          >
          > In the Finance Bill 2008 published today the Minister has unveiled the new
          > rules that will apply to the use of “Green” diesel for private pleasure
          > navigation in RoI.
          >
          > The Press release is at http://www.finance.gov.ie/viewdoc.asp?DocID=5162and
          > there are links to the bill and the explanatory memorandum at the bottom
          > of
          > the page.
          >
          > From 1 Novemeber the rate of duty will be 368.05 Euro per 1000 litres –
          > the
          > same as road diesel. Thats in Section 65 on page 91.
          >
          > Section 66 on then goes on to explain how the tax-man will collect the
          > extra
          > revenue:
          > ===================begins==============
          > Subsection (a) iii defines “private pleasure craft” as follows:
          > ”’private pleasure navigation’ means navigation in any craft, by its
          > owner
          > or the natural or legal person who enjoys its use either through hire or
          > through any other means, for other than commercial purposes, and in
          > particular other than for the carriage of passengers or goods, the supply
          > of
          > services for consideration or for the purposes of public authorities;”,
          >
          > Subsection (c) then says:
          >
          > (c) by inserting the following after section 97-
          >
          > 97A.-(1) Subject to subsections (2) and (3), heavy oil which has been
          > taxed
          > at the rate specified in Schedule 30 2 for other heavy oil (referred to in
          > this section as ”marked gas oil”) may be used for private pleasure
          > navigation.
          >
          > (2) Where subsection (1) applies, the owner of the craft used for private
          > pleasure navigation shall, not later than the first day of March following
          > the calendar year in which the marked gas oil was purchased for such use,
          > deliver to an officer-
          >
          > (a) a return, in such form as the Commissioners may require, of the
          > quantity
          > in litres of marked gas oil purchased in that calendar year, and
          >
          > (b) payment of an amount of mineral oil tax calculated at the rate of
          > 32.069
          > cent per litre (which is the difference between the mineral oil tax rate
          > for
          > marked gas oil
          > and the rate for heavy oil used for private pleasure navigation) on such
          > quantity
          >
          > (3) The owner referred to in subsection (2) shall, together with vouched
          > receipts for all purchases of the marked gas oil concerned, maintain a
          > record of such purchases, in such form as the Commissioners may require.
          > ==========ends================
          > The somewhat confusing wording arises because what the 2008 Bill does is
          > amend an earlier Act.
          >
          > My reading (and I’m only a simple engineer, not a parliamentary
          > draughtsman
          > or a lawyer) is that from 1 November of this year we will be required to
          > keep a record of any “Green” diesel we buy for our boats along with the
          > receipts and then between 1-January and 31-March each year make a return
          > to
          > the revenue saying how much we bought and enclosing a cheque for the extra
          > duty payable.
          >
          > Two things aren’t clear to me:
          >
          > 1) What happens if I buy “Red” diesel in Northern Ireland
          >
          > and
          >
          > 2) How hirers of hire-boats will cope (because my reading is that the
          > hirers
          > will be liable for the extra duty.)
          >
          > These are questions that we will pose to the Powers That Be in the Dept.
          > of
          > Finance.
          >
          > Colin Becker
          > Project/Development Officer, IWAI
          > “IWAI – The Voice of the Waterways”
          >
          >

        • Noel Griffin
          Participant
            Post count: 4935

            Hi Colin

            That’s good news and a victory for common sense. That means diesel will
            typically cost €1.16 per litre instead of 80c which is not as bad as the
            doomsday merchants would have led us all to beleive, and certainly NOT
            double the price of “green”.

            Noel

          • watertalk1
            Spectator
              Post count: 353

              more importantly it doesnt affect the current sources of supply and is self
              administered by the users

              Colin, Theres no confusion about hirers. They simply have to make the same
              return ( you dont have to own the boat)

              As to Northern ireland, Not really something we should ask the dept.

              I suspect that it will be just ignored.

              dave

              a great victory for common sense

            • Noel Griffin
              Participant
                Post count: 4935

                Hi Dave

                > more importantly it doesnt affect the current sources of supply and is
                > self administered by the users

                This is a great option, because if Marina’s had been forced to stock white
                diesel, they and the few road tankers with white permits would have charged
                considerably more than “road” prices due to the small volumn and tiny
                margines. This way the green/red supply chain remains untouched, and all we
                have to do is pay the 36.8c duty per litre to the tax man once a year.

                Interesting question though if not relevant inland:
                Given UK and ROI will continue to legally permit the use and storage of
                red/green diesel in leisure boats, collecting the extra duty later – How
                will a UK or ROI boat arriving in France, Spain or Holland be treated with
                tanks full of red/green?

                Did sir humphrey think of that one ;)

                Noel

              • Mick Farrell
                Spectator
                  Post count: 3492

                  OK…so now we finally know…it seems a very reasonable solution to the
                  issue. Fair play to those who’ve lobbied on our behalves…!!!
                  Now….a question….I seem to recall someone stating on here a while back
                  that white diesel actually burns cleaner than green….(????) Given that
                  I seldom use riverside pumps and that green is now effectivlely the same
                  price as white, would it be to my advantage to just use white anyway…??

                  M(W&W)F

                • watertalk1
                  Spectator
                    Post count: 353

                    Mick , Marked gas Oil , particulary the makeup used in Ireland , is
                    inferiour to road diesel ( DERV). Generally old engines prefer the green
                    diesel as it has a greater lubricating effect, whereas modern boat engines
                    and derived from car diesels and prefer road diesel.

                    As to pricing I suspect that green diesel will remain a bit cheaper as its
                    will be bought in bulk , whereas its hard to get bulk deliveries of road
                    diesel to a boat.

                    Dave

                  • Neil Arlidge
                    Participant
                      Post count: 40

                      Colin,

                      You a star!..God, the IWAI is with-it getting info out so quickly.
                      No doubt the UK will follow…..most of the uk boating groups / IWA heard it
                      first via you!

                      There is the question about how much duty you pay back to the govt. if (like
                      many UK/ROI boats) you only have one tank for engine / heating /
                      cooking…also interesting if the propulsion engine has a 230v AC generator,
                      and could just be used for that purpose, like mine.
                      Another question …what will a UK (mainland) resident do, that keeps his
                      boat in the ROI, buys most of his diesel in the ROI, but is only an hours
                      cruising away from the NI??!!

                      Neil Arlidge – NB Earnest – Shannon Reg 7410
                      Read about the TNC Irish travels at:
                      http://www.tuesdaynightclub.co.uk/Tour_07/index.html
                      Defend The Waterways:
                      http://www.saveourwaterways.org.uk/

                      Colin Becker (Project Officer, IWAI) wrote:
                      > Greetings,
                      >
                      > In the Finance Bill 2008 published today the Minister has unveiled
                      > the new rules that will apply to the use of “Green” diesel for
                      > private pleasure navigation in RoI.
                      >
                      > The Press release is at
                      > http://www.finance.gov.ie/viewdoc.asp?DocID=5162 and there are links
                      > to the bill and the explanatory memorandum at the bottom of the page.
                      >
                      > From 1 Novemeber the rate of duty will be 368.05 Euro per 1000 litres
                      > – the same as road diesel. Thats in Section 65 on page 91.
                      >
                      > Section 66 on then goes on to explain how the tax-man will collect
                      > the extra revenue:
                      > ===================begins==============
                      > Subsection (a) iii defines “private pleasure craft” as follows:
                      > ”’private pleasure navigation’ means navigation in any craft, by its
                      > owner or the natural or legal person who enjoys its use either
                      > through hire or through any other means, for other than commercial
                      > purposes, and in particular other than for the carriage of passengers
                      > or goods, the supply of services for consideration or for the
                      > purposes of public authorities;”,
                      > Subsection (c) then says:
                      >
                      > (c) by inserting the following after section 97-
                      >
                      > 97A.-(1) Subject to subsections (2) and (3), heavy oil which has been
                      > taxed at the rate specified in Schedule 30 2 for other heavy oil
                      > (referred to in this section as ”marked gas oil”) may be used for
                      > private pleasure navigation.
                      >
                      > (2) Where subsection (1) applies, the owner of the craft used for
                      > private pleasure navigation shall, not later than the first day of
                      > March following the calendar year in which the marked gas oil was
                      > purchased for such use, deliver to an officer-
                      >
                      > (a) a return, in such form as the Commissioners may require, of the
                      > quantity in litres of marked gas oil purchased in that calendar year,
                      > and
                      > (b) payment of an amount of mineral oil tax calculated at the rate of
                      > 32.069 cent per litre (which is the difference between the mineral
                      > oil tax rate for marked gas oil
                      > and the rate for heavy oil used for private pleasure navigation) on
                      > such quantity
                      >
                      > (3) The owner referred to in subsection (2) shall, together with
                      > vouched receipts for all purchases of the marked gas oil concerned,
                      > maintain a record of such purchases, in such form as the
                      > Commissioners may require. ==========ends================
                      > The somewhat confusing wording arises because what the 2008 Bill does
                      > is amend an earlier Act.
                      >
                      > My reading (and I’m only a simple engineer, not a parliamentary
                      > draughtsman or a lawyer) is that from 1 November of this year we will
                      > be required to keep a record of any “Green” diesel we buy for our
                      > boats along with the receipts and then between 1-January and 31-March
                      > each year make a return to the revenue saying how much we bought and
                      > enclosing a cheque for the extra duty payable.
                      >
                      > Two things aren’t clear to me:
                      >
                      > 1) What happens if I buy “Red” diesel in Northern Ireland
                      >
                      > and
                      >
                      > 2) How hirers of hire-boats will cope (because my reading is that the
                      > hirers will be liable for the extra duty.)
                      >
                      > These are questions that we will pose to the Powers That Be in the
                      > Dept. of Finance.
                      >
                      > Colin Becker
                      > Project/Development Officer, IWAI
                      > “IWAI – The Voice of the Waterways”
                      >
                      >
                      >

                    • M. G. Kerr
                      Spectator
                        Post count: 6

                        Neil wrote “Another question …what will a UK (mainland) resident do, that
                        keeps his boat in the ROI,”

                        To digress from the matter of the diesel for a moment, most the natives on
                        this island regard the “mainland” as the chunk of land that starts at Calais
                        and runs east from there. The UK just like Ireland is also an island. There
                        is another UK contributor to this forum that used to refer to the UK as the
                        “mainland” but he saw the light !

                        With best nautical regards,

                        Maurice

                        m.s. Angelique

                        Tel. +353 86 2547 947

                        mailto:mgkerr[AG]indigo.ie

                        The information contained in this e-mail is confidential. it is intended
                        only for the addressee(s) stated above. If you are not the addressee, any
                        use, dissemination, distribution or copying of the information contained in
                        this e-mail is strictly prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in
                        error, please notify me immediately by telephone on +353 86 2547 947 or by
                        e-mail at mgkerr[AG]indigo.ie and delete the e-mail from your system. It is
                        your responsibility to scan this e-mail and any attachments for
                        viruses.Thank you for your co-operation.

                        Colin,

                        You a star!..God, the IWAI is with-it getting info out so quickly.

                        No doubt the UK will follow…..most of the uk boating groups / IWA heard it

                        first via you!

                        There is the question about how much duty you pay back to the govt. if (like

                        many UK/ROI boats) you only have one tank for engine / heating /

                        cooking…also interesting if the propulsion engine has a 230v AC generator,

                        and could just be used for that purpose, like mine.

                        Another question …what will a UK (mainland) resident do, that keeps his

                        boat in the ROI, buys most of his diesel in the ROI, but is only an hours

                        cruising away from the NI??!!

                        Neil Arlidge – NB Earnest – Shannon Reg 7410

                        Read about the TNC Irish travels at:

                        http://www.tuesdaynightclub.co.uk/Tour_07/index.html

                        Defend The Waterways:

                        http://www.saveourwaterways.org.uk/

                        Colin Becker (Project Officer, IWAI) wrote:

                        > Greetings,

                        >

                        > In the Finance Bill 2008 published today the Minister has unveiled

                        > the new rules that will apply to the use of “Green” diesel for

                        > private pleasure navigation in RoI.

                        >

                        > The Press release is at

                        > http://www.finance.gov.ie/viewdoc.asp?DocID=5162 and there are links

                        > to the bill and the explanatory memorandum at the bottom of the page.

                        >

                        > From 1 Novemeber the rate of duty will be 368.05 Euro per 1000 litres

                        > – the same as road diesel. Thats in Section 65 on page 91.

                        >

                        > Section 66 on then goes on to explain how the tax-man will collect

                        > the extra revenue:

                        > ===================begins==============

                        > Subsection (a) iii defines “private pleasure craft” as follows:

                        > ”’private pleasure navigation’ means navigation in any craft, by its

                        > owner or the natural or legal person who enjoys its use either

                        > through hire or through any other means, for other than commercial

                        > purposes, and in particular other than for the carriage of passengers

                        > or goods, the supply of services for consideration or for the

                        > purposes of public authorities;”,

                        > Subsection (c) then says:

                        >

                        > (c) by inserting the following after section 97-

                        >

                        > 97A.-(1) Subject to subsections (2) and (3), heavy oil which has been

                        > taxed at the rate specified in Schedule 30 2 for other heavy oil

                        > (referred to in this section as ”marked gas oil”) may be used for

                        > private pleasure navigation.

                        >

                        > (2) Where subsection (1) applies, the owner of the craft used for

                        > private pleasure navigation shall, not later than the first day of

                        > March following the calendar year in which the marked gas oil was

                        > purchased for such use, deliver to an officer-

                        >

                        > (a) a return, in such form as the Commissioners may require, of the

                        > quantity in litres of marked gas oil purchased in that calendar year,

                        > and

                        > (b) payment of an amount of mineral oil tax calculated at the rate of

                        > 32.069 cent per litre (which is the difference between the mineral

                        > oil tax rate for marked gas oil

                        > and the rate for heavy oil used for private pleasure navigation) on

                        > such quantity

                        >

                        > (3) The owner referred to in subsection (2) shall, together with

                        > vouched receipts for all purchases of the marked gas oil concerned,

                        > maintain a record of such purchases, in such form as the

                        > Commissioners may require. ==========ends================

                        > The somewhat confusing wording arises because what the 2008 Bill does

                        > is amend an earlier Act.

                        >

                        > My reading (and I’m only a simple engineer, not a parliamentary

                        > draughtsman or a lawyer) is that from 1 November of this year we will

                        > be required to keep a record of any “Green” diesel we buy for our

                        > boats along with the receipts and then between 1-January and 31-March

                        > each year make a return to the revenue saying how much we bought and

                        > enclosing a cheque for the extra duty payable.

                        >

                        > Two things aren’t clear to me:

                        >

                        > 1) What happens if I buy “Red” diesel in Northern Ireland

                        >

                        > and

                        >

                        > 2) How hirers of hire-boats will cope (because my reading is that the

                        > hirers will be liable for the extra duty.)

                        >

                        > These are questions that we will pose to the Powers That Be in the

                        > Dept. of Finance.

                        >

                        > Colin Becker

                        > Project/Development Officer, IWAI

                        > “IWAI – The Voice of the Waterways”

                        >

                        >

                      • Colin Becker
                        Moderator
                          Post count: 5097

                          Neil wrote….

                          > You a star!..God, the IWAI is with-it getting info out so quickly.
                          > No doubt the UK will follow…..most of the uk boating groups / IWA heard
                          > it first via you!

                          Colin (blushing)>>>>We aim to please……

                          > There is the question about how much duty you pay back to the govt. if
                          > (like many UK/ROI boats) you only have one tank for engine / heating /
                          > cooking…also interesting if the propulsion engine has a 230v AC
                          > generator, and could just be used for that purpose, like mine.

                          Colin>>>>That doesn’t appear to be catered for in the bill. I will ask the
                          question of the Powers That Be…..

                          > Another question …what will a UK (mainland) resident do, that keeps his
                          > boat in the ROI, buys most of his diesel in the ROI, but is only an hours
                          > cruising away from the NI??!!

                          Colin>>>>I think, as Dave has explained, the issue is where you buy the
                          fuel. If you buy marked gas oil in the Republic, you will have an
                          obligation to make a return to the Irish Revenue every year of how much you
                          bought and to send them a cheque for the duty owing. Regardless of where
                          you actually live or indeed keep the boat. Quite how they will enforce that
                          is unclear.
                          We haven’t seen anything from HM Revenue folks but from what I’m hearing,
                          they will probably adopt a similar approach.

                          Best Wishes,

                          Colin

                        • Miriam Henderson
                          Spectator
                            Post count: 13

                            Hear, hear….

                            Ramsay

                          • watertalk1
                            Spectator
                              Post count: 353

                              “Quite how they will enforce that
                              is unclear.”

                              it will be enforced in the same way as they enforce cross border speeding
                              fines or parking tickets. ie they will not bother, its simplu not worth the
                              enforcement costs.

                              Dave

                              As to heating propulsion, that is catered for . The act refers to use in
                              propolusion ( or navigation) so just deduct teh amount “you” think your
                              heater uses and remit the amount.

                              Its like all self assesment taxes , you evaluate whats right and submit the
                              return

                            • Neil Arlidge
                              Participant
                                Post count: 40

                                Maurice,

                                I said UK Mainland, as I am a UK (Mainland) resident and not resident in UK
                                (NI)…maybe I should have said Britain…but then again that would pee some
                                people off…I do try to be politically correct…Maybe I should have said
                                “The big island of the Celtic Archepelago”. The reason I split things off
                                this way, is that is the way the main navigation authorities / inland
                                boating is split (though there are some that would say that British
                                Waterways (Scotland) is as good as a separate entity to the rest of British
                                Waterways.

                                Neil Arlidge – NB Earnest – Shannon Reg 7410
                                Read about the TNC Irish travels at:
                                http://www.tuesdaynightclub.co.uk/Tour_07/index.html
                                Defend The Waterways:
                                http://www.saveourwaterways.org.uk/

                                M. G. Kerr wrote:
                                > Neil wrote “Another question …what will a UK (mainland) resident
                                > do, that keeps his boat in the ROI,”
                                >
                                >
                                >
                                > To digress from the matter of the diesel for a moment, most the
                                > natives on this island regard the “mainland” as the chunk of land
                                > that starts at Calais and runs east from there. The UK just like
                                > Ireland is also an island. There is another UK contributor to this
                                > forum that used to refer to the UK as the “mainland” but he saw the
                                > light !
                                >
                                >
                                >
                                > With best nautical regards,
                                >
                                >
                                >
                                > Maurice
                                >
                                > m.s. Angelique
                                >
                                >
                                >
                                > Tel. +353 86 2547 947
                                >
                                > mailto:mgkerr[AG]indigo.ie

                              • graylion1
                                Spectator
                                  Post count: 7

                                  The name of said island is Great Britain I think … ;)

                                  Bernhard

                                  Neil Arlidge wrote:
                                  >
                                  > Maurice,
                                  >
                                  > I said UK Mainland, as I am a UK (Mainland) resident and not resident in
                                  > UK (NI)…maybe I should have said Britain…but then again that would
                                  > pee some people off…I do try to be politically correct…Maybe I
                                  > should have said “The big island of the Celtic Archepelago”. The reason
                                  > I split things off this way, is that is the way the main navigation
                                  > authorities / inland boating is split (though there are some that would
                                  > say that British Waterways (Scotland) is as good as a separate entity to
                                  > the rest of British Waterways.
                                  >
                                  > Neil Arlidge – NB Earnest – Shannon Reg 7410
                                  > Read about the TNC Irish travels at:
                                  > http://www.tuesdaynightclub.co.uk/Tour_07/index.html
                                  > Defend The Waterways:
                                  > http://www.saveourwaterways.org.uk/
                                  >
                                  > M. G. Kerr wrote:
                                  >> Neil wrote “Another question …what will a UK (mainland) resident
                                  >> do, that keeps his boat in the ROI,”
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >> To digress from the matter of the diesel for a moment, most the
                                  >> natives on this island regard the “mainland” as the chunk of land
                                  >> that starts at Calais and runs east from there. The UK just like
                                  >> Ireland is also an island. There is another UK contributor to this
                                  >> forum that used to refer to the UK as the “mainland” but he saw the
                                  >> light !
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >> With best nautical regards,
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >> Maurice
                                  >>
                                  >> m.s. Angelique
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >>
                                  >> Tel. +353 86 2547 947
                                  >>
                                  >> mailto:mgkerr[AG]indigo.ie
                                  >
                                  >
                                  >

                                • Neil Arlidge
                                  Participant
                                    Post count: 40

                                    Sorry, us Canucks get confused!

                                    Neil Arlidge – NB Earnest – Shannon Reg 7410
                                    Read about the TNC Irish travels at:
                                    http://www.tuesdaynightclub.co.uk/Tour_07/index.html

                                    Miriam Henderson wrote:
                                    > Hear, hear….
                                    >
                                    > Ramsay
                                    >

                                  • watertalk1
                                    Spectator
                                      Post count: 353

                                      hey guys , lets not get picky mainland, islands, blah blah , I know what
                                      you mean, I have no probkems, call it,here there whatever you like.

                                      PS Neil, The best is not to justify oneself, thast usually makes it worse.

                                      Lads and lassies, lets leave the discussions on nomenclature for
                                      http://www.politics.ie, or boards.ie or wherever.

                                      To misquote Calvin and Hobbs, “Guinness and medals all round”

                                      Dave

                                    • Noel Griffin
                                      Participant
                                        Post count: 4935

                                        Hi Dave

                                        Hear hear, agree 100% well said. No need for sniping ;) ;)

                                        > hey guys , lets not get picky mainland, islands, blah blah , I know what
                                        > you mean, I have no probkems, call it,here there whatever you like.
                                        >
                                        > PS Neil, The best is not to justify oneself, thast usually makes it worse.
                                        >
                                        > Lads and lassies, lets leave the discussions on nomenclature for
                                        > http://www.politics.ie, or boards.ie or wherever.
                                        >
                                        > To misquote Calvin and Hobbs, “Guinness and medals all round”
                                        >
                                        > Dave

                                      • Mick Farrell
                                        Spectator
                                          Post count: 3492

                                          Maurice,

                                          Surely the term “the mainland” is relative one. I doubt that someone standing on the Arran Islands would be refering to the European Mainland if they were to use that expression. I also feel that the phrase “UK (mainland)” is a reasonable one to describe the larger portion of these 2 non contigious landmasses…!!!

                                          M(W&W)F

                                        • John.Kinsella1
                                          Spectator
                                            Post count: 2768

                                            IMHO UK mainland seem a perfectly reasonable term for the larger of the
                                            two neighbouring islands.

                                            What sometimes irritates people is when (usually in N. Ireland but not
                                            always) people refer to the neighbouring island as “the mainland”

                                            An extreme case in my experience was when on an island off the Irish
                                            West coast years ago (don’t remember which but we got there by boat) I
                                            asked two Scots girls when they were going back to the mainland.

                                            They said not for a few days…

                                            My confusion was followed by a little general embarrassment when they
                                            realised I meant Clare (or wherever) and I realised that they meant
                                            (Great) Britain… :-)

                                            John

                                            Mick Farrell wrote:
                                            > Maurice,
                                            > Surely the term “the mainland” is relative one. I doubt that someone
                                            > standing on the Arran Islands would be refering to the European
                                            > Mainland if they were to use that expression. I also feel that the
                                            > phrase “UK (mainland)” is a reasonable one to describe the larger
                                            > portion of these 2 non contigious landmasses…!!!
                                            > M(W&W)F
                                            >
                                            >

                                          • Marguerite & Stephen Maher
                                            Spectator
                                              Post count: 260

                                              OK why do we not just call our patch the colonies ?

                                              Stephen Maher,

                                              Gerda

                                              Dutch Boat

                                            • Neil Arlidge
                                              Participant
                                                Post count: 40

                                                …anway, thus is getting just like uk.rec.waterways…let’s get back on
                                                topic… ;-)

                                                Glad to see that we have compleatly wrongfooted the uk news groups, telling
                                                them what will be happening to their red diesel.
                                                I notice Ocean Froggie at work on ybw.

                                                Neil Arlidge – NB Earnest – Shannon Reg 7410
                                                Read about the TNC Irish travels at:
                                                http://www.tuesdaynightclub.co.uk/Tour_07/index.html

                                                Marguerite & Stephen Maher wrote:
                                                > OK why do we not just call our patch the colonies ?
                                                >
                                                >
                                                > Stephen Maher,
                                                >
                                                > Gerda
                                                >
                                                > Dutch Boat
                                                >

                                              • Mick Farrell
                                                Spectator
                                                  Post count: 3492

                                                  Ahhhh sure we need these occasionl little digressions. It keeps the topic
                                                  of the GPS thingys…LOL. Did Noel tell it straight or did he sneak in
                                                  any “ball hopping”…???

                                                  M(W&W)F

                                                • Noel Griffin
                                                  Participant
                                                    Post count: 4935

                                                    Some of us live in a country on the larger part of an island which is a political entity called the republic of Ireland, which is part a collection of islands geographically referred to as the British Isles – get over it. :) We’re all just part of the human race. :) :) The term “mainland” is used wholly and exclusively on Fr Ted’s Craggy Island. :) :) The EU is the politically correct term for the German/Franco controlled alliance that governs 23 other member states, administered by Brussels sprouts, who caused the whole green/red diesel problem in the first place. Chill out fellow humans. :)

                                                    Noel

                                                  • michael moroney
                                                    Spectator
                                                      Post count: 187

                                                      Noel

                                                      Give them some more archaic bits to chew – we are ( the inhabitants of this
                                                      western isle all of us) the original ‘west brits’ the other lot were johhny
                                                      come latelys, they arrived in 1169 at least the french advance party of
                                                      them did mainly now concentrated in wexford (dna)- the diminutive ‘brit’
                                                      short for anglo saxon ‘british’ a descriptive noun for the breton – celts
                                                      the inhabitants of these islands prior to 1066 and all that – breton is
                                                      celtic as in brittany fr.– get a grip lads . after all we had political
                                                      control east to the welsh/english border area up to the 8th century.The dna
                                                      says the true centre of the 21st century ‘brit’ bioculture is castlebar –
                                                      thats the datum check it – cumbria/nth yorkshire shares the same dna
                                                      profile as do the majority in wales and s.western eng.- so the historical
                                                      description for the western european archipelago of islands should be the
                                                      ‘british isleas’ modified spelling to include our basque cousins who fell
                                                      of the trolley en route – oh yes we are still part of the human race on
                                                      reflection we are probably a goodly part of it given the dispora and our
                                                      fondness for the fair sex .

                                                      Mike

                                                      Mike Moroney ( moroneymf[AG]eircom.net )

                                                    • shane1
                                                      Spectator
                                                        Post count: 1235

                                                        I know someone who used to regard the USA as a colony !.

                                                        > OK why do we not just call our patch the colonies ?
                                                        >
                                                        >

                                                    Viewing 24 reply threads
                                                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                    Go to Top